Imagine you’re at the grocery store. The prices seem reasonable, maybe even a little lower than last month. You breathe a sigh of relief, thinking the inflation worries are finally easing. Then, you get home and check your credit card bill. The interest charges are higher than ever. Or perhaps your mortgage renewal notice arrives, and the new rate makes your heart sink. This is the reality many Americans are facing: a disconnect between what official inflation numbers say and what our wallets tell us.
While government reports focus on the rising costs of goods and services, they often overlook a significant factor impacting our financial lives – the cost of money itself, primarily interest payments. Are we truly understanding the economic pressures we face, or are we missing a crucial piece of the puzzle?
The Official Inflation Narrative: A Limited View of Rising Costs
- What it Means: The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) tracks the prices of a basket of everyday items – think groceries, gas, clothing, and rent. They release the Consumer Price Index (CPI), which tells us how much these prices have changed over time. (1)
- Example: When you hear “inflation is 3%,” it means the average price of these items has gone up by 3% in a year.
- Why it Matters (and Where it Falls Short): This data is essential for understanding the overall economy. It helps policymakers make decisions. However, it primarily focuses on current spending. It doesn’t fully capture the impact of past borrowing or the future costs of financing those purchases. For example, if you bought a house two years ago, the official inflation numbers won’t show the increased strain of rising mortgage rates on your budget today.
The Reality of Rising Interest Costs: The Hidden Squeeze on Household Budgets
- What it Means: Your actual cost of living is more than just the price tags at the store. It includes the cost of borrowing money.
- Example: If you have a car loan, credit card debt, or a mortgage, rising interest rates mean you’re paying more each month, even if the price of the car or house itself hasn’t changed.
- Why it Matters: These increased interest payments eat into your disposable income, leaving less money for other necessities or savings. This creates a hidden financial burden that official inflation figures often don’t reflect. People feel the pinch, even if the government says things are stable.
The Argument for Including Interest Payments: A More Complete Picture
- What it Means: Economists like Lawrence Summers argue that we should go back to a way of calculating inflation that includes the cost of borrowing. (2)
- Example: Before 1983, the BLS considered mortgage interest when calculating inflation. If we did that today, we’d see a much higher inflation rate.
- Why it Matters: This would provide a more accurate reflection of the financial strain on households. It would acknowledge that rising interest rates directly impact people’s ability to afford their current lifestyles. This would help create policies that better address the true cost of living.
Reassessing Inflation Measurement: Why Your Mortgage Matters More Than Ever
- What it Means: The way we measure inflation has changed, and it may not be keeping up with the modern economy.
- Example: The current method, “owners’ equivalent rent,” tries to estimate how much homeowners would pay if they were renting. It doesn’t fully account for the impact of rising mortgage rates on homeowners’ budgets. This aims to represent the cost of the housing service consumed by homeowners, regardless of whether they rent or own.
- Why it Matters: With rising rates, many homeowners face significantly higher monthly payments. This creates financial stress that isn’t captured by the official inflation figures. We need a measurement that reflects the reality of how interest rates impact household finances.
Empowering Informed Financial Decisions
In conclusion, it’s undeniably important to grasp the true impact of interest payments and the potential underestimation of inflation’s burden on households. While these economic factors present challenges, a well-crafted financial strategy can empower you to navigate and potentially overcome these obstacles.
As a financial professional, we understand the complexities of these issues and can help you develop a customized approach tailored to your specific circumstances. If you’re feeling the pinch of inflation more acutely than you anticipate, or if you’re seeking clarity on how to incorporate these concepts into your financial approach, we invite you to schedule a complimentary meeting. Let’s discuss how to help build a robust financial future, even in the face of economic uncertainty.
Click on the “contact me” button below to schedule a complimentary meeting.
Sources:
-
(1) Fernando, Jason. “What Is the Consumer Price Index (CPI)?” Investopedia, 25 Feb. 2025, www.investopedia.com/terms/c/consumerpriceindex.asp
-
(2) Roy, Avik. “Summers: Inflation Reached 18% In 2022 Using the Government’s Previous Formula.” Forbes, 23 Mar. 2024, www.forbes.com/sites/theapothecary/2024/03/23/summers-inflation-reached-18-in-2022-using-the-governments-previous-formula/
This information is being provided only as a general source of information and is not intended to be the primary basis for financial decisions. It should not be construed as advice designed to meet the particular needs of an individual situation. Please seek the guidance of a financial professional regarding your particular financial concerns. Consult with your tax advisor or attorney regarding specific tax issues. We are not affiliated with or endorsed by any government agency and do not provide tax or legal advice or services.
